The rest of the pantheon include (center-left to right): a wistful Boss Tweed as Pluto (or Hades), god of the underworld; over him, Manton Marble, editor of the New York World, as Atlas bearing the world on his shoulders; Senator Reuben Fenton of New York as Mercury, god of Commerce and the divine thief, stands behind Reid/Apollo; James Gordon Bennett Jr., editor of the New York Herald and an avid yachtsman, is King Neptune; Chief Justice Salmon Chase, perennial seeker of the presidency, is Diana, goddess of hunting and chastity; seated center-top is Senator Charles Sumner of Massachusetts as Jupiter, god of thunder; continuing rightward is vice-presidential nominee Gratz Brown as Bacchus, god of wine, wearing a wreath of crabs and sitting astride a watermelon, with a generous lump of butter at his side (recalling his inebriation at a Yale dinner at which he reportedly buttered his watermelon); and, on the far right-center, Senator Carl Schurz as Mars, god of war.

The cherubs around the globe are (counterclockwise from the top-left): Peter Sweeny of Tammany Hall; New York City Mayor Oakey Hall; New York Governor John Hoffman; August Belmont, former chairman of the Democratic Party; John Morrissey of Tammany Hall; Congressman James Brooks (wearing glasses) of New York; Thomas Ledwith of Tammany Hall; ex-President Andrew Johnson; and Tom Fields of Tammany Hall. The four flying in the center are (left-right): Benjamin Wood (smoking), editor of the New York Daily News; Sheriff Matthew Brennan of New York City; Congressman Fernando Wood of New York; and Horatio Seymour, the 1868 Democratic presidential nominee. The cherubs on the right are (left-right): Senator Thomas Tipton of Nebraska; Senator Lyman Trumbull of Illinois; Senator James Doolittle of Wisconsin; and Hugh Kilpatrick, a former Union general.